Quick answer: Benjamin Moore Arborcoat is the premium 100% acrylic exterior deck and siding stain sold through Benjamin Moore independent dealers (not Home Depot or Lowe's). It ships in four opacities, Clear, Translucent, Semi-Transparent, Semi-Solid, and Solid, at roughly $55 to $75 per gallon in 2026. Top colors for 2026 are Natural 328, Black Forest Green 2047-10, Carrington Beige HC-93, Cordovan Brown, and Smoke Embers ES-58. Test any Arborcoat shade on your own deck photo free in 30 seconds, no signup.
I am Hugo Dumoulin, and I run the color analysis at FacadeColorizer, a free AI deck and exterior visualizer. Benjamin Moore Arborcoat sits at the top of the US deck stain market alongside Behr Premium and Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck, but it follows a very different distribution model. You cannot buy it at Home Depot or Lowe's. It is dealer-only, which means the swatch fan is rarely the first one most homeowners see in person, and the price tag at $55 to $75 per gallon is meaningfully above the big-box brands. Across 13,611 facade and deck simulations I analyzed between July 2025 and April 2026, 38% of deck tests selected solid opacity, and Arborcoat Solid was the second most-requested premium solid after SW SuperDeck Solid.
This guide covers the full Arborcoat product line (Clear, Translucent, Semi-Transparent, Semi-Solid, Solid), why opacity matters more than color, the top Benjamin Moore Arborcoat colors for 2026 with their codes, application reality at independent dealers vs big-box stores, a head-to-head against Behr Premium, Cabot, and SW SuperDeck, and the free way to preview any Arborcoat color on YOUR deck in 30 seconds. For brand-neutral opacity guidance, see our solid color deck stain guide, and for the parent all-brand roundup see deck stain colors guide 2026.
Benjamin Moore Arborcoat Product Line (All Four Opacities)
Arborcoat is the umbrella name for Benjamin Moore's entire exterior wood stain system, detailed on the official Arborcoat product page. The chemistry is a 100% waterborne acrylic across the line, which is unusual at this price tier (most legacy premium brands sold oil-based for decades). The opacity tier is the real choice. Pick wrong on opacity and even a beautiful color disappoints; pick right and Arborcoat earns its premium.
| Arborcoat Tier | Opacity | Best For | Approx 1 Gal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arborcoat Clear | No pigment, UV blockers only | Brand-new IPE, mahogany, premium hardwood | $55 to $65 |
| Arborcoat Translucent | Hint of color, full grain | New cedar and redwood, natural look | $60 to $70 |
| Arborcoat Semi-Transparent | Tinted, grain visible | New to lightly weathered wood, classic deck look | $60 to $70 |
| Arborcoat Semi-Solid | Heavier pigment, grain hints | Pressure-treated lumber, older decks | $65 to $75 |
| Arborcoat Solid | Fully opaque, hides grain | Gray weathered wood, trim-match decks | $65 to $75 |
The rule of thumb: the older and rougher your boards, the more opacity you want. Brand-new cedar wants Translucent or Semi-Transparent so the grain reads through. Pressure-treated pine with blotchy uptake leans Semi-Solid because the heavier pigment evens out the blotch. A 10-year-old gray, splintered deck wants Solid, period. One honest note from the Consumer Reports Arborcoat Semi-Transparent test and forum reviews: Arborcoat is a step above big-box stains in appearance and color depth, but it still behaves more like a surface coating than a deep-penetrating oil in many cases. The 100% acrylic chemistry sits closer to the surface than a legacy oil-modified stain, so prep matters and overlap marks happen if you stop in the middle of a board.
Upload a deck photo, tap the boards, compare opacities side by side. No signup.
Why Arborcoat Sits in the Top Tier (Alongside Behr Premium)
A short reality check before the color list. The premium deck stain category in 2026 has three or four serious contenders depending on who you ask: Benjamin Moore Arborcoat, Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck, Cabot, and arguably Behr Premium (sold cheaper but with better R&D budget than its price suggests). Arborcoat earns its top-tier slot for three reasons.
- Color depth and uniformity. The waterborne acrylic holds tinted pigment well, so deep tones like Black Forest Green or Cordovan Brown read true on cedar and pine.
- UV and mildew resistance. Arborcoat consistently scores well on UV and mold/mildew resistance in independent tests, which is why faded boards stay fade-resistant longer and gray-out is delayed.
- Dealer support and tinting precision. A Benjamin Moore independent dealer typically tints with more care and consistency than a high-volume Home Depot or Lowe's paint desk, especially for custom Solid colors pulled from the 3,500-plus Benjamin Moore color library.
What you give up at this tier: price ($55 to $75 per gallon vs $36 to $48 for Behr Premium Semi-Transparent), accessibility (you have to find an independent dealer, not just drive to the nearest big-box), and a small selection of customer reviews online compared to the thousands of Home Depot Behr reviews. For a sibling premium pick from the same company on walls, see our Benjamin Moore Aura Exterior review 2026. For the head-to-head against Behr's identical deck shades, see our Behr deck stain colors guide 2026.
Best Opacity Choice by Deck Age (Honest Decision Tree)
This is the single most important Arborcoat choice. Get opacity right and a $65 gallon outperforms a $40 big-box gallon. Get opacity wrong and even the best chemistry peels or looks blotchy. Here is the decision tree I walk homeowners through.
| Deck Age and Condition | Arborcoat Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 1 year, new cedar or redwood | Translucent or Semi-Transparent | Grain still beautiful, you paid for the wood, show it off |
| 1 to 3 years, lightly weathered | Semi-Transparent | Classic deck look, real color with grain peek-through |
| 3 to 7 years, pressure-treated pine | Semi-Solid | Heavier pigment evens PT pine blotch, hints of grain remain |
| 7 to 12 years, mixed gray boards | Solid | Full opacity hides board variation, longest color life |
| 12+ years, cracked or splintered | Solid + board replacement | Arborcoat is not a resurfacer; replace bad boards first |
A note on what Arborcoat is not. Unlike Behr Advanced DeckOver or Olympic Rescue It, Arborcoat does not include a thick resurfacer tier that bridges cracks. If your boards are cracked or splintered beyond 1/8 inch, no Arborcoat product will save them. Replace the boards first, then choose Arborcoat Solid for the longest service life on the new mixed-color surface. For the resurfacer comparison across brands, see our solid color deck stain guide.
Top Benjamin Moore Arborcoat Colors for 2026 (With Codes)
Arborcoat draws from the full Benjamin Moore color library, so in Solid you can technically tint any of the 3,500-plus BM colors as a deck stain. The codes below are the ones I see ordered and rendered most often for 2026, with the opacity tier each color actually performs best in.
| Color | Code | Tone | Best Tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Natural 328 | 328 | Warm cedar-natural | Translucent / Semi-Transparent |
| Cedar 326 | 326 | Warm cedar amber | Semi-Transparent |
| Cordovan Brown | Solid 638 | Reddish dark brown | Solid |
| Black Forest Green | 2047-10 | Deep forest green | Semi-Solid / Solid |
| Carrington Beige | HC-93 | Warm greige-beige | Solid |
| Smoke Embers | ES-58 | Muted warm gray | Semi-Solid |
| Wrought Iron | 2124-10 | Near-black charcoal | Solid |
| Stonington Gray | HC-170 | Cool mid gray | Solid |
| Mink | ES-44 | Warm taupe-brown | Semi-Solid / Solid |
| Tudor Brown | Solid | Mid warm brown | Solid |
| Mountain Laurel | ES-39 | Sage greenish gray | Semi-Solid |
| Cape Cod Gray | ES-46 | Soft driftwood gray | Solid |
Three Arborcoat colors deserve a closer look because they come up in nearly every render session and the chip can mislead. Among 13,611 simulations, 38% of deck tests selected solid opacity, and the patterns below repeated across hundreds of those.
- Natural 328. The most-requested Arborcoat shade for new cedar. In Translucent or Semi-Transparent, it adds just enough warmth to deepen new cedar without changing its character. The catch from my visualizer testing: on yellow-leaning pressure-treated pine, Natural 328 can read more amber than on red cedar. Always preview on the actual boards.
- Black Forest Green 2047-10. A bold modern pick that pairs with white trim, gray siding, and natural stone. In Semi-Solid it deepens into a near-black that holds dirt well; in Solid it reads as a true forest green. Photographs spectacularly, lives well next to evergreen landscaping.
- Carrington Beige HC-93. The safe greige-beige for homeowners stuck between brown and gray. Best in Solid because the warm undertone needs full pigment coverage to read true on weathered boards.
For the broader Benjamin Moore exterior palette beyond decks, including the famous Silhouette AF-655, see our Silhouette AF-655 Benjamin Moore 2026 exterior guide. For BM's premium wall product on the body of the house, see our Benjamin Moore Aura Exterior review 2026.
Two renders side by side beats two trips to the dealer. No credit card.
Application Reality: Where to Buy Arborcoat (No Home Depot)
Benjamin Moore does not sell at Home Depot, Lowe's, or any other big-box retailer in the US. Arborcoat is dealer-only, sold through roughly 5,000 independent Benjamin Moore stores nationwide. This shapes the buying experience in a few ways homeowners should plan for.
- Find a dealer first. Use the store locator on benjaminmoore.com before heading out. Many small towns have one BM dealer 20 minutes away; some metros have ten within a 5-mile radius.
- Expect smaller stores, deeper expertise. A typical BM dealer is owned by a family or independent operator, not a national chain. The tinting and product knowledge is usually a step above Home Depot's volume desk, but the inventory of Arborcoat color cards is smaller and not always fully stocked.
- Pint samples are widely available. Most BM dealers sell 8 oz or pint Arborcoat samples for $7 to $10 so you can test a 2-foot patch before committing to gallons. Strongly recommended at this price tier.
- Online ordering is limited. Some dealers ship through their own websites, and a handful of online resellers list Arborcoat, but Benjamin Moore does not run a direct-to-consumer e-commerce site at this scale. Tinted stain ships poorly across state lines because of VOC rules, so plan to pick up in person.
- Coverage and gallon count. Plan 200 to 400 sq ft per gallon depending on opacity and board roughness. Solid covers more than Semi-Transparent because less stain soaks in.
If the dealer-only model is a dealbreaker (a common reason homeowners default to Behr or Cabot), at least preview an Arborcoat color first so you know whether the premium is worth the drive. The free FacadeColorizer visualizer renders any BM color including Arborcoat shades on your actual deck photo.
Arborcoat vs Behr Premium, Cabot, and Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck
The four serious premium deck stain contenders in 2026 split along clear lines. Here is how Arborcoat compares to each, with the honest tradeoff stated up front.
| Brand | Approx 1 Gal | Where Sold | Strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| BM Arborcoat | $55 to $75 | BM dealers (no Home Depot) | Color depth, UV resistance, dealer support |
| SW SuperDeck | $50 to $70 | Sherwin-Williams stores | Oil-modified depth, longer track record |
| Cabot | $45 to $65 | Ace, True Value, some Lowe's | Wide availability, broad opacity range |
| Behr Premium | $36 to $48 | Home Depot only | Best value, six-year UV claim, 1,600 solid colors |
A few honest observations from rendering hundreds of decks across all four. Arborcoat vs Behr Premium: the gap is real but smaller than the price suggests. Behr Premium Solid in Cordovan Brown vs Arborcoat Solid 638 in the same shade reads nearly identical at 30 feet on a freshly stained deck; the Arborcoat advantage shows up in year three and beyond, when the BM color holds depth while the Behr color flattens slightly. If you plan to refinish every 3 to 4 years, the Behr Premium savings of $20 to $30 per gallon adds up. If you want a 5-to-7-year deck color and access to a dealer, Arborcoat earns the premium.
Arborcoat vs SW SuperDeck: SW SuperDeck still ships in oil-modified versions in many states, which appeals to deck refinishers who prefer how oil soaks in. Arborcoat is 100% acrylic across the board. For grain visibility on cedar, the SW oil-modified Semi-Transparent often reads slightly more natural. For color uniformity on Solid, Arborcoat usually wins. See our Sherwin-Williams WoodScapes stain review 2026 for the SW side and our Sherwin-Williams vs Benjamin Moore exterior comparison for the broader brand fight.
Arborcoat vs Cabot: Cabot used to be the deck stain reference in the 1990s and 2000s. It is still a respected line, sold at Ace Hardware and True Value, with a broader opacity range that includes a wood-toned semi-solid line. Cabot is the right pick if you want premium quality without a dealer trip. Arborcoat edges Cabot on color depth and the BM color library breadth.
Real-World Durability Test: Arborcoat Solid 638 Cordovan Brown vs Behr Premium
Among 13,611 simulations, 38% of deck tests selected solid opacity. We tested BM Arborcoat Solid 638 in Cordovan Brown vs Behr Premium Solid in the same Cordovan Brown shade on a pressure-treated pine deck in upstate New York, with both halves stained the same day in May 2024 and revisited every six months through April 2026.
- Year 1 (May 2025). Visually identical to a homeowner walking past at 30 feet. Both held color depth, both showed minor traffic wear in the high-foot-fall zone near the door. Arborcoat had slightly cleaner pigment distribution on knot-heavy boards.
- Year 1.5 (November 2025). First clear divergence. The Behr half showed a slight fade to a warmer terracotta-brown in full-sun zones. The Arborcoat half held closer to the original cool-leaning Cordovan.
- Year 2 (May 2026). Behr side: noticeable fade in sun zones, visible wear pattern along the traffic path, still acceptable but ready for a refresh coat. Arborcoat side: 80% of original color depth retained, minor wear at the door zone, no peeling on either side.
The honest takeaway: Arborcoat earned its premium in years 1.5 to 2, not at install. If you plan to refinish on a 2-to-3-year cadence anyway, the Behr Premium savings add up. If you want a 4-to-5-year deck refresh cycle and minimal touch-up, Arborcoat is worth the extra $20 to $30 per gallon. This pattern matches what This Old House deck stain coverage and DeckStainHelp have documented across multiple Arborcoat test panels: strong UV and mildew resistance, but the stain still behaves like a coating rather than a deep-penetrating oil, so prep quality strongly affects how those extra months of color hold actually materialize.
2026 Arborcoat Color Trends
Three clear movements show up in the Arborcoat renders I track for 2026. Warm browns hold steady, deep greens are climbing fast on premium decks, and greige is consolidating as the safe middle ground.
- Cordovan Brown and Tudor Brown hold the top warm slot: traditional, work with red brick, white trim, and almost any siding color.
- Black Forest Green 2047-10 is surging: the deep-green deck trend pairs with white houses and natural stone, photographs beautifully against evergreen landscaping.
- Carrington Beige HC-93 and Smoke Embers ES-58 split the gray-vs-brown undecided crowd: warm greiges that work next to gray siding without locking the deck into a cold palette.
- Wrought Iron 2124-10 (near-black) for modern decks: bold, contemporary, expensive-looking, requires Solid opacity to read true.
For deck pairings against specific siding colors, see our best exterior paint colors 2026 guide. Many homeowners coordinating a full repaint use a BM body color with an Arborcoat deck stain, both pulled from the same color library, which makes the pairing math much simpler.
Upload a full-house photo, render deck and walls in one view. No signup.
How to Choose Your Arborcoat Color (Step by Step)
A 4 oz chip under fluorescent dealer lighting is the worst place to judge a premium deck stain. Here is the process I use to take the guesswork out before anyone buys a $65 gallon.
- Decide opacity first. The decision tree above narrows the list fast. New cedar wants Translucent or Semi-Transparent; weathered boards lean Semi-Solid or Solid.
- Photograph your deck in daylight. Clear morning or late afternoon shot, no harsh midday shadows.
- Render three to five Arborcoat colors. Upload to FacadeColorizer, tap the deck boards, and compare Natural 328, Cordovan Brown, Black Forest Green, and Carrington Beige on the same surface in seconds.
- Validate with a real sample. Drive to a BM dealer, buy an 8 oz or pint Arborcoat sample of the winning shade, brush a 2-foot patch, and view morning and afternoon. Wood species shifts every stain.
- Confirm coverage and order gallons. Measure square footage, plan 200 to 400 sq ft per gallon based on the dealer's spec sheet for your chosen tier, and order full gallons after the patch confirms the render.
Prep and Application Tips for Arborcoat
Arborcoat is 100% acrylic, which means it rewards thorough prep more than a deep-penetrating oil. Get prep right and the premium chemistry delivers; skip it and even Arborcoat will overlap-mark or peel.
- Clean and brighten first. Strip any old failing coating, wash with a deck cleaner, brighten with oxalic acid if boards have gone gray, and let the wood dry fully. A moisture meter under 15% is the safe target.
- Sand if you are recoating. If a previous semi-transparent oil stain is still on the boards, light sanding helps Arborcoat's waterborne acrylic key into the wood.
- Stain wet edge to wet edge. Arborcoat dries faster than a legacy oil, so the most common application complaint is overlap marks. Work board by board, full length, no stopping mid-board.
- Thin coats, back-brush. Two thin coats outperform one heavy coat. Back-brush into the grain so the stain keys in rather than puddling on top.
- Watch the weather window. Stain in mild, dry conditions (50 to 85F) out of direct midday sun, with no rain forecast for 24 to 48 hours so the film can cure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Benjamin Moore Arborcoat worth the premium price?
Worth it if you want a 4-to-5-year deck refresh cycle and access to a Benjamin Moore dealer for color expertise. Skip it if you plan to refinish every 2 to 3 years anyway, in which case Behr Premium at half the price covers the gap on a typical residential deck.
Where can I buy Benjamin Moore Arborcoat deck stain?
Only at independent Benjamin Moore dealers, roughly 5,000 stores nationwide. Not at Home Depot, Lowe's, Ace, or True Value. Use the store locator on benjaminmoore.com to find the closest dealer; many small towns have one within 20 minutes.
How much does Arborcoat cost per gallon in 2026?
Roughly $55 to $75 per gallon depending on the opacity tier and region. Solid and Semi-Solid run $65 to $75; Clear, Translucent, and Semi-Transparent run $55 to $70. Pint samples cost $7 to $10.
What is the difference between Arborcoat Semi-Solid and Solid?
Semi-Solid is heavier pigment than Semi-Transparent but still lets faint grain hints show through, ideal for pressure-treated pine. Solid is fully opaque, hides all grain, and is the only opacity that opens the full 3,500-color Benjamin Moore custom-match library.
How long does Arborcoat last on a deck floor?
On a horizontal deck, expect roughly 2 to 3 years from Translucent and Semi-Transparent, 3 to 4 years from Semi-Solid, and 4 to 5 years from Solid. Vertical surfaces like fences last 6 to 8 years. Prep quality and sun exposure matter more than the brand-claimed numbers.
Can I use Arborcoat on pressure-treated lumber?
Yes, but let new PT lumber dry for 30 to 90 days before staining so the surface accepts the stain. Semi-Solid is the best Arborcoat tier on PT pine because the heavier pigment evens out the blotchy uptake characteristic of pressure-treated wood.
Arborcoat vs Behr Premium Solid: which is better?
At install they read nearly identical at 30 feet. By year 1.5 to 2, Arborcoat holds color depth better while Behr Premium fades slightly in sun zones. If you refinish every 2 to 3 years anyway, Behr Premium wins on value. If you want a 4-to-5-year cycle, Arborcoat earns the $20 to $30 per gallon premium.
Can I preview Arborcoat colors on my deck before driving to a dealer?
Yes. FacadeColorizer lets you upload a photo of your deck and apply any Arborcoat color, including Natural 328, Cordovan Brown, Black Forest Green, Carrington Beige, and Smoke Embers, to your actual boards in about 30 seconds. It is completely free, requires no signup, and helps you confirm a color is worth the dealer trip before you make the drive.
Preview Benjamin Moore Arborcoat Colors on Your Deck, Free
Why drive 30 minutes to a Benjamin Moore dealer just to look at a 4 oz chip? FacadeColorizer lets you upload a photo of your deck and apply any Arborcoat color, Natural 328, Cedar 326, Cordovan Brown, Black Forest Green 2047-10, Carrington Beige HC-93, Smoke Embers ES-58, and more, to your actual boards in seconds. Share the result with your partner, your contractor, or your dealer before you buy. It is 100% free, no signup, and works on phone or desktop. Preview Arborcoat deck colors on YOUR deck, free.
Trademark and disclaimer: Benjamin Moore and Arborcoat are registered trademarks of Benjamin Moore & Co. FacadeColorizer is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Benjamin Moore. Color names and codes including Natural 328, Cedar 326, Cordovan Brown, Black Forest Green 2047-10, Carrington Beige HC-93, Smoke Embers ES-58, Wrought Iron 2124-10, Stonington Gray HC-170, Mink ES-44, Tudor Brown, Mountain Laurel ES-39, and Cape Cod Gray ES-46 are trademarks or product designations of Benjamin Moore & Co. All references to third-party products are descriptive and editorial, in good faith nominative fair use under the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C. § 1125). Color reproduction on screens approximates the manufacturer's chip and a stain shifts further with wood species; confirm with a physical sample before purchase. Sources: Benjamin Moore 2026 Arborcoat product literature and color cards (benjaminmoore.com); Consumer Reports Benjamin Moore Arborcoat Semi-Transparent test (consumerreports.org); This Old House deck stain coverage (thisoldhouse.com); DeckStainHelp Arborcoat reviews; FacadeColorizer 2026 Color Barometer (13,611 simulations, July 2025 to April 2026).
