Brand Reviews

Sherwin-Williams Andiron SW 6174 on a house: a near-black olive at LRV 5, on wood and fiber cement siding, stucco and trim, with the vinyl rule and the colors that go with it

Modern farmhouse with board-and-batten siding painted a very dark olive green, off-white window trim, cedar porch posts and a black metal roof in autumn

Try it on your house

Andiron SW 6174 outside: LRV 5.13, hex #424036, store strip 278-C6, siding and stucco, the vinyl rule, trim whites and the closest dark greens.
5 min read

Sherwin-Williams Andiron (SW 6174) is a near-black olive: its LRV is 5.13, so it reflects about 5 percent of visible light and reads as a deep green-charcoal from the street. Sherwin-Williams files it in its Green family, flags it as a dark color in its color data and states that it is for interior and exterior projects; its store strip is 278-C6. Outside, it works best on wood or fiber cement siding, stucco, doors and accents, but not on vinyl siding, where the Sherwin-Williams exterior product sheet rules out colors this dark.

The LRV, RGB, Lab, family, coordinating colors and store strip come from Sherwin-Williams' public color data and the Andiron color page. The coverage, temperature and surface rules come from the Duration Exterior product data sheet; the vinyl list from the VinylSafe page. Hue angles, color differences and gallon counts are our calculations; advice on light, trim and roofs is our color reasoning. Hex and RGB are an approximate digital rendering, so judge the color on a painted board outside.

See Andiron on a photo of your house

The link opens the exterior tool with Andiron preselected on the walls. Switch to the door, the shutters or the trim in the same photo.

Andiron SW 6174 in numbers

The name, the number and the Green family come from the Andiron color page on sherwin-williams.com. The other values come from the brand's public color data, read on 20/11/2026.

AttributeAndiron SW 6174
LRV5.13 (flagged dark by Sherwin-Williams)
RGB66, 64, 54
Hex (screen approximation)#424036
Lab (brand color data)L 26.99, a -1.20, b 6.43
Interior and exteriorBoth
CollectionTimeless Color Wall
Store strip278-C6
Coordinating colors listed by the brandYellow Bird SW 9022, Mannered Gold SW 6130, and Moderne White SW 6168 as the white

Try it on your house

  1. 1Your photoPhoto
  2. 2Your colorColor
  3. 3HD render in ~30 sHD render in ~30 s
No photo? Try a sample

Your photo is used only to create your preview. JPG, PNG, HEIC (iPhone)

Green, gray or brown? What the Lab values say

An L value of 27 puts Andiron deep in the dark range: for comparison, Tricorn Black SW 6258 has an LRV of 2.85 and Iron Ore SW 7069 an LRV of 5.55 in the same color data. The a value (-1.20) leans slightly green and the b value (+6.43) leans yellow, which is the recipe for olive. By our calculation the chroma is about 6.5 and the hue angle about 101 degrees, a muted yellow-green: little color, a lot of depth.

Our color reasoning: on the house, that low chroma means Andiron reads as charcoal in shade and on cloudy days, and the green shows in low, warm sun or next to foliage. It is greener than Iron Ore, which sits almost exactly on the neutral axis, and less brown than Sealskin SW 7675. If your aim is a black house with a hint of nature, Andiron is a softer option than a true black; if you want a clearly green house, look at a mid-tone green instead.

How a near-black olive reads in sun and shade

A color that reflects 5 percent of the light shows the texture of the wall more than its hue. On board-and-batten, the battens cast shadow lines that read darker still, and the boards between them catch the light. On lap siding, every course adds a thin shadow under the lap. On smooth stucco, Andiron reads as a flat dark plane, which suits a modern house and can feel heavy on a small one.

Orientation changes the reading. A north-facing wall stays in shade most of the day and shows Andiron at its most charcoal. A west-facing wall in late afternoon brings out the olive. Paint a board about two feet square with two coats, hold it against the siding in the morning and the late afternoon, and look at it from the street. For a darker reference on the same board, add a strip of Tricorn Black, which we cover in the Tricorn Black exterior guide.

Siding and coverage: what the Duration sheet says

The exterior sheet used here is Sherwin-Williams' Duration Exterior Acrylic Flat product data sheet, K32 series. It states that the paint is self-priming on most surfaces, that it takes two coats on new, bare surfaces and one coat for a repaint, and that coverage is 250 to 300 square feet per gallon. The surfaces it lists include wood, cement composition siding and panels, aluminum siding, stucco, concrete block and plywood.

By our calculation, 1,500 square feet of siding takes 5 to 6 gallons per coat at that rate. A switch from a light color to Andiron is a large jump in darkness, so plan for two coats even on sound paint: a single coat of a dark color over a light one can leave thin areas that show at the edges and on the battens. That puts a light-to-dark repaint of 1,500 square feet at 10 to 12 gallons, before trim and doors. For the brand's other lines, our Duration exterior review and the Sherwin-Williams exterior paint guide compare the products.

JobCoatsGallons for 1,500 sq ft (our calculation)
Repaint of a dark color in Andiron1 (per the sheet)5 to 6
Light color to Andiron2 (our recommendation)10 to 12
New, bare surface2 (per the sheet)10 to 12

Vinyl siding: why Andiron is ruled out

The Duration sheet says not to paint vinyl or other PVC products with a color darker than the original, or with a Light Reflective Value below 56, unless VinylSafe colors are used, because the vinyl may warp. Andiron has an LRV of 5.13, more than 50 points under that line, and it is not on the VinylSafe colors page, which listed 99 swatches with SWVS codes when we checked it on 20/11/2026.

That page says the VinylSafe palette includes "a limited selection of darker colors" formulated to resist warping on sound vinyl, applied with lines such as Emerald, Duration, SuperPaint or Latitude. If the house is vinyl and you want a dark olive look, choose from that palette, not from the general chart, and check the vinyl maker's rules too. Our VinylSafe paint guide explains the system. Do not decide a vinyl job from this guide alone.

Stucco, brick and new masonry

The Duration sheet lists stucco among its surfaces and asks for new stucco to cure at least 30 days before painting; if the job cannot wait, the surface must dry 7 days and be primed with Loxon Concrete & Masonry Primer. Cracks and voids are repaired first, and loose stucco and efflorescence removed. On stucco, Andiron reads as a flat dark mass, and the texture makes it a little softer than on smooth siding.

Brick is a bigger decision. Paint on porous brick is hard to remove, so painting it near-black is close to permanent. Our color reasoning: if the goal is a dark brick house, test a hidden wall first and let it weather for a few weeks. Painting only the trim and the door in Andiron and keeping the brick natural is the reversible option, and it suits orange or brown brick, where the olive of Andiron picks up the green of the garden.

Craftsman bungalow with its shingle and lap siding painted a dark olive gray, cream porch columns on stone piers, white windows and a wood front door
The craftsman bungalow from our sample photos with its siding changed to Andiron SW 6174. The cream columns, stone piers and wood door are unchanged; in full daylight the painted wall reads a little lighter than the chip.

Trim, windows and doors: the whites and the accents

The coordinating white that Sherwin-Williams lists for Andiron is Moderne White SW 6168 (LRV 74.47), a white with a gray-beige cast. Against an LRV of 5, any white gives a strong outline; the question is how warm it should look. Our color reasoning: Moderne White keeps the contrast soft and earthy; Alabaster SW 7008 (LRV 82.22) is warmer and brighter; Pure White SW 7005 (LRV 83.96) is the crispest of the three.

ElementColorLRVOur color reasoning
SidingAndiron SW 61745.13The base; test it in sun and in shade
Trim (soft contrast)Moderne White SW 616874.47The brand's coordinating white
Trim (warm, bright)Alabaster SW 700882.22Warmer outline, suits cedar and stone
Window sashes, doorsTricorn Black SW 62582.85Tone-on-tone dark, for modern houses
AccentMannered Gold SW 613034.50The brand's coordinating mid-tone; a door or porch ceiling

Natural wood is the classic partner of a dark olive: cedar porch posts, a stained front door or a wood soffit. The brand's coordinating list also offers Yellow Bird SW 9022 (LRV 63.84), a strong yellow that suits a front door if you want one bright note. Black window frames and Andiron siding give a monochrome look where the frames almost disappear; white frames keep the windows readable.

Roofs and landscape

Our color reasoning on roofs: a black or charcoal roof sits naturally on Andiron, and the house reads as one dark volume with white trim lines. A brown or weathered-wood shingle roof stays warm against the olive, which works on a cabin or a craftsman. A light gray roof against near-black siding gives the strongest contrast and can make the roof look bigger than it is. A standing seam metal roof in black is the modern farmhouse version.

Around the house, a near-black olive makes green planting look brighter and makes a pale gravel path or a concrete walk stand out. In a wooded lot, it lets the house recede into the trees; on an open lot in full sun, it makes the house a strong dark shape. Check the HOA or historic district rules before a dark repaint, since those rules can restrict exterior colors.

Andiron next to the other dark Sherwin-Williams exteriors

The brand's color data lists several similar colors. We sorted them by color difference to Andiron on screen (Delta E 2000, our calculation; 2 to 3 is visible side by side, above 4 is a different color).

ColorLRVHexDelta E 2000 to AndironOur reading
Sealskin SW 76755.56#48423C4.1Browner
Ripe Olive SW 62096.16#44483D4.3Greener, a little lighter
Iron Ore SW 70695.55#4343414.7Neutral charcoal
Laurel Woods SW 77496.28#44493D5.0Greener
Clove SW 96055.05#453E395.0Brown-black

None of these is a substitute: at a Delta E of 4 or more, the difference shows on a board. Ripe Olive is the one to compare if you like the green side of Andiron, and Iron Ore if you like its charcoal side. We cover both in the Ripe Olive exterior guide and the Iron Ore exterior guide. For a lighter green from the same brand, see the Oakmoss exterior guide.

The closest Benjamin Moore color

On the Benjamin Moore side, the closest color we found on screen is River Rock 2139-10, with an LRV of 6.6 and a screen color of #464233 on the brand's page. By our calculation, the color difference to Andiron is about 2.6: close, but visible side by side, and River Rock is slightly lighter and a touch more yellow. It is a closest match, not an equivalent, so paint both samples on one board before you switch brands.

When to paint: temperature, dew point and dark colors in sun

The Duration sheet sets the limits: air, surface and material temperatures above 35°F (1.7°C) and at least 5° above the dew point, and no painting when rain or snow is expected within 2 to 3 hours. It also warns that the surface can be colder than the air. In late fall, short days and dew leave a narrow window, so start late in the morning and stop early enough for the film to set before evening.

A dark color adds one rule of thumb, which is our reasoning: a wall that absorbs 95 percent of the light warms quickly in direct sun, and paint on a hot wall dries before it levels, which leaves lap marks. Follow the shade around the house: paint the east side in the afternoon and the west side in the morning. Keep a wet edge and finish a full wall section between corners or trim lines in one go.

Lead and older houses

If the house was built before 1978, check the old paint before you scrape or sand. The EPA's Renovation, Repair and Painting Program page says that about three quarters of US homes built before 1978 still contain some lead-based paint, and that anyone paid to disturb painted surfaces in those homes must be certified. The Duration sheet adds that scraping, sanding or removing old paint may release lead dust, and that lead is toxic. Keep children out of the work area while the surface is prepared.

Test Andiron on your house before you order

A near-black changes a house more than any chip suggests. Upload a photo of the front, apply Andiron to the siding, then try it on the door and shutters only, and compare the two versions. Then compare it with Ripe Olive or Iron Ore in the same photo. When the choice is made, confirm it with a painted board outside.

Try Andiron on my house

Walls, trim, door or shutters, one photo.

For other dark choices from the brand, the Urbane Bronze exterior guide covers the brown-gray side, and our green exterior paint colors hub compares greens from light to dark.

Sources and references

Frequently asked questions

What color is Sherwin-Williams Andiron?
Andiron SW 6174 is a near-black olive. Sherwin-Williams files it in its Green family and gives it an LRV of 5.13, so it reads as a deep green-charcoal outside, with the green showing most in warm, low sun.
Can Andiron be used on exterior siding?
Yes on wood, fiber cement, stucco and the other surfaces listed in the Duration Exterior product data sheet. Not on vinyl: the sheet rules out colors with an LRV below 56 on vinyl unless VinylSafe colors are used, and Andiron (LRV 5.13) is not on the VinylSafe list.
What trim color goes with Andiron?
Sherwin-Williams lists Moderne White SW 6168 as the coordinating white. Alabaster SW 7008 gives a warmer, brighter outline and Pure White SW 7005 a crisper one. Natural cedar and black window frames also suit a dark olive.
Is Andiron darker than Iron Ore?
Slightly. Andiron has an LRV of 5.13 and Iron Ore SW 7069 an LRV of 5.55. The bigger difference is the undertone: Andiron leans olive, Iron Ore is a neutral charcoal.
What is the Benjamin Moore equivalent of Andiron?
There is no official equivalent. By our screen comparison, the closest Benjamin Moore color is River Rock 2139-10 (LRV 6.6), with a visible difference of about 2.6 Delta E 2000. Paint both samples side by side before switching.

Trademarks mentioned (Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, Behr, Caparol, Brillux, Sto, Alpina, Valspar, PPG, Glidden, Dulux, Crown Trade, Sandtex, Farrow & Ball, Johnstone's, Leyland) are property of their respective owners. FacadeColorizer is independent and not affiliated with any of them. Nominative fair use under Lanham Act §1125.

Share this article with your neighborhood:

Related articles and color guides

Ready to customize your home color?

Color visualizer

Try it on YOUR photos - customize your home color

Stop guessing. Our AI analyzes your photo and renders a photorealistic color preview in 30 seconds - optimized for American homes, neighborhoods and ZIP code-level light conditions.

Start a free color simulation