Color Inspiration

Benjamin Moore Thunder AF-685 on a house: a light warm gray at LRV 47.58, on siding, stucco, brick and trim, the vinyl limit, the whites and doors that go with it, and Thunder vs Revere Pewter

Two-story American house with horizontal lap siding painted a light warm gray, white window trim and porch posts, a charcoal front door, a gray shingle roof and a low stone foundation

Try it on your house

Thunder AF-685 outside: a light warm gray at LRV 47.58. Siding, stucco, brick, the vinyl limit, trim whites, doors, and Thunder vs Revere Pewter.
5 min read

Benjamin Moore Thunder (AF-685) is a light mid-tone gray with a faint warm cast: a greige that stays on the gray side. Benjamin Moore describes it as "an easy-to-use neutral that offers an ideal mix of warm and cool", files it in its Affinity Color Collection, publishes an LRV of 47.58 and an RGB of 189, 184, 173 (hex #BDB8AD), and lists Vapor AF-35, Dolphin AF-715, Cloud White 967 and Smoke 2122-40 as coordinating colors. Outside, it works as a body color on wood, fiber cement, stucco and painted brick with a white trim, and as a soft trim or door color on a lighter house. The main limit is vinyl siding: at 47.58 it is under Benjamin Moore's LRV floor for vinyl and off its Colors for Vinyl card.

Color values come from Benjamin Moore's pages and color data. Lab values, chroma, color differences (ΔE2000), LRV gaps and gallon counts are our calculations from those figures; advice on light and pairings is our color reasoning.

See Thunder on a photo of my house

The link opens the exterior tool with Thunder preselected on the walls. How it works: our exterior paint visualizer.

Thunder at a glance: the numbers Benjamin Moore publishes

These values come from the color's page (Benjamin Moore, Thunder AF-685) and the color data it loads. Hex and RGB are an approximate screen rendering: judge the color on a painted sample.

AttributeThunder AF-685
LRV47.58
RGB189, 184, 173
Hex (screen approximation)#BDB8AD
CollectionAffinity Color Collection
Color familyNeutral, also tagged Gray
UseInterior and exterior (Benjamin Moore color data)
Coordinating colors listedVapor AF-35, Dolphin AF-715, Cloud White 967, Smoke 2122-40
Similar colors listedHimalayan Trek 1542, Shale 861, La Paloma Gray 1551, Silver Fox 2108-50
Lighter and darker shades listedCalm 2111-70, Abalone 2108-60, River Reflections 1552, Equestrian Gray 1553, Stampede 979, Evening Grove 1526
PaletteColor Trends 2020

Try it on your house

  1. 1Your photoPhoto
  2. 2Your colorColor
  3. 3HD render in ~30 sHD render in ~30 s
No photo? Try a sample

Your photo is used only to create your preview. JPG, PNG, HEIC (iPhone)

The Affinity Color Collection page counts 144 colors, numbered AF-5 to AF-720, and presents them as a set chosen to work together. Thunder also belongs to Benjamin Moore's Color Trends 2020 palette, ten colors built around First Light 2102-70, a soft pink, where Thunder is cast as the neutral at the center. Cloud White 967 on the coordinating list is the same color as Cloud White OC-130: same hex, same LRV of 85.05.

Is Thunder gray or greige? Its undertones, warm and cool

It is a gray with a little warmth. Converted from its published RGB, Thunder's Lab values are about L 74.9, a -0.2 and b 6.2 (our calculation): no red or pink, a modest yellow, a chroma of about 6.2 and a hue angle near 92 degrees, almost on the yellow axis. In practice: no purple or pink cast in shade, a soft beige note in direct sun.

The table places it among the grays it gets compared with (LRV from Benjamin Moore; Lab and chroma are our calculation from the published RGB):

ColorCollectionLRVLab a / bChromaReads as
Metropolitan AF-690Affinity49.96-2.0 / 2.22.9A cool gray; Benjamin Moore calls its undertones cool
Stonington Gray HC-170Historical Colors59.36-1.4 / 2.93.2A lighter, silvery gray
Thunder AF-685Affinity47.58-0.2 / 6.26.2A gray with a light warm cast
Revere Pewter HC-172Historical Colors55.05-0.7 / 7.67.7A lighter and slightly warmer greige
Edgecomb Gray HC-173Historical Colors63.09-0.5 / 8.28.2A light greige, the warmest of the five

Thunder sits in the middle: about twice the chroma of Metropolitan or Stonington Gray, a little less than Revere Pewter, which is why it passes for both a gray and a greige. Daylight moves it the same way (our color reasoning): a north wall cools it toward a flat gray, late western sun pushes it toward beige, and red brick or a brown roof bring out its warmth.

What an LRV of 47.58 means on a house

LRV runs from 0 (black) to 100 (white). At 47.58, Thunder reflects a little under half of the visible light that reaches it: light for a gray, but under the line several building-product makers draw between light and dark colors.

SurfacePublished ruleThunder at 47.58
Vinyl siding, Aura ExteriorBenjamin Moore's Aura Exterior Flat data sheet (N629): nothing darker than the original or under LRV 57 unless on the Colors for Vinyl palette, as the siding may absorb heat and warpAbout 9 points under, and not on the palette: out
Vinyl siding, Regal Select ExteriorThe Regal Select Exterior Low Lustre data sheet (W103, July 2021): the same rule with an LRV floor of 55About 7 points under: out
Cellular PVC trimAZEK's Classic White Trim technical data sheet (2025): over LRV 55, a 100% acrylic latex exterior paint; under 55, its approved paint chartsCheck AZEK's charts first
Wood front doorSimpson Door's Paint It Black page: LRV 55 or below is a dark color, and warranty coverage requires a door built to that program's specificationsCounts as dark: read the door's warranty
Garage doorClopay's painting instructions (effective May 11, 2020): from LRV 39 to 100, solar reflective paint is recommended, not required, on every door lineAllowed; solar reflective paint optional
Wood, fiber cement, stucco, masonry, aluminumListed among Aura Exterior's surfaces with no LRV limit statedAllowed

These are product rules, not a building code: before Thunder goes on vinyl, PVC trim or a wood door, look up the LRV rule in that product's instructions.

Siding, stucco, brick, vinyl: where Thunder works

Wood, fiber cement and hardboard siding

The Aura Exterior Flat data sheet lists wood, fiber cement, hardboard, vinyl and aluminum siding, shakes, unglazed brick, concrete, stucco, block and primed metal, and calls the paint self-priming on most properly prepared substrates; redwood and cedar take a Fresh Start primer first. Our board and batten paint guide covers that layout.

Stucco and masonry

Per the same sheet, new masonry must cure for 30 days before painting, and surfaces with a pH of 10 or more take Ultra Spec Masonry Sealer (608) or Masonry High Build Primer (N609) first. Our Benjamin Moore stucco paint guide goes through the products.

Brick: painted, or left bare beside Thunder siding

The Brick Industry Association's Technical Note 6, Painting Brick Masonry states that clay masonry requires no painting and that, once painted, exterior masonry will need repainting every three to five years. It asks for a porous paint so the wall can breathe, and for efflorescence to be removed first. Left bare, red brick is an easy neighbor for Thunder siding in our view: the paint carries no red to fight the clay. Our painted brick guide covers the process.

Vinyl siding: pick from the vinyl card instead

Thunder is not on Benjamin Moore's Colors for Vinyl color card, so on vinyl both data sheets rule it out. By our calculation from Benjamin Moore's screen colors, the closest colors on that card are:

  • Silver Fox 2108-50 (LRV 43.73, about ΔE 2.2): listed as similar on Thunder's own page, a touch darker with a hint more red.
  • Revere Pewter HC-172 (LRV 55.05, about ΔE 3.8): lighter, with nearly the same hue.
  • Metropolitan AF-690 (LRV 49.96, about ΔE 4.5): its Affinity neighbor, as light but cooler.

The card also asks you to check the siding maker's guidelines first. Our guide to painting vinyl siding with Aura and the Sherwin-Williams VinylSafe guide cover both brands' palettes.

Garage door, front door, shutters

Clopay also asks for a 100% acrylic latex exterior paint and states that ignoring its instructions voids the door's warranty; on vinyl or PVC shutters, the vinyl and PVC rules above apply. See our garage door color ideas and the exterior shutter colors guide.

Two-story Colonial house with its lap siding painted Thunder, a light warm gray, with white window trim, portico and columns, a navy front door, a gray shingle roof and a detached garage with white doors
The navy Colonial from our sample photos with the siding of the house and garage changed to Thunder AF-685: the white trim, navy door and gray roof are unchanged. The shadow lines of the lap boards make the wall look a little deeper than the paint chip.

Trim, door and accent colors with a Thunder body

The four colors Benjamin Moore lists with Thunder are marked; the gap is the LRV difference from Thunder (Benjamin Moore's published LRVs), and the effect column is our color reasoning.

RoleColorLRVGapEffect
Trim (listed)Cloud White OC-130 / 96785.05+37.5Soft and balanced: a gentle outline
Trim (listed)Vapor AF-3581.60+34.0Muted cream undertones: the most tonal option
TrimWhite Dove OC-1783.16+35.6Soft, a little less warm than Cloud White
TrimSwiss Coffee OC-4581.91+34.3A warm white: helps a north wall
TrimChantilly Lace OC-6590.04+42.5The crispest: Thunder looks warmer
TrimDecorator's White OC-14982.68+35.1A touch of cool gray: a more graphic front
Shutters, door (listed)Dolphin AF-71523.71-23.9Same collection, darker: a tonal accent
Door, porch ceiling (listed)Smoke 2122-4056.39+8.8Blue-green undertones: a soft color accent
Door, shuttersHale Navy HC-1548.36-39.2Navy against a warm gray: a classic contrast
Door, shuttersWrought Iron 2124-108.17-39.4A soft black with no color cast
DoorSilhouette AF-65510.18-37.4Espresso and charcoal: the warm dark of the collection
Shutters, garage doorKendall Charcoal HC-16614.61-33.0A charcoal: less stark than black

A white with about the same warmth as Thunder (Cloud White, Swiss Coffee, Vapor) gives a calm, tonal front; a cooler white (Chantilly Lace, Decorator's White) sharpens the outline and pushes Thunder toward greige. Our guides to Cloud White OC-130 outside, White Dove OC-17 outside and Decorator's White OC-149 outside cover each white as trim. For the door, see the Hale Navy HC-154 exterior guide, the Wrought Iron 2124-10 exterior guide, the Silhouette AF-655 page and our Benjamin Moore front door colors.

Thunder as the trim or accent on a lighter house

On a White Dove or Swiss Coffee body, a Thunder trim sits about 34 to 36 LRV points darker: enough to draw the windows and corner boards without the hard edge of black. On a Stonington Gray body (LRV 59.36) the gap shrinks to about 12 points, a tonal look better kept for shutters or a door. For a two-tone house, the shade list on Thunder's page gives a ladder of close hue: Abalone 2108-60 (LRV 61.99) above, River Reflections 1552 (35.28) below.

Thunder vs Revere Pewter HC-172

The difference is mostly depth. Revere Pewter is about 7.5 LRV points lighter, with nearly the same hue and slightly more warmth. By our calculation the color difference is about 3.8 ΔE2000, most of it lightness: side by side on a wall, Revere Pewter looks like a lighter step of Thunder rather than a different color.

Thunder AF-685Revere Pewter HC-172
LRV47.5855.05
Hex (screen)#BDB8AD#CBC6B8
CollectionAffinity Color CollectionHistorical Colors
How Benjamin Moore describes itAn easy neutral mixing warm and coolA neutral that bridges warm and cool tones
Chroma (our calculation)6.27.7
Coordinating colors listedVapor, Dolphin, Cloud White, SmokeChelsea Gray HC-168, White Dove OC-17, Sparrow AF-720, Fog Mist OC-31
On the Colors for Vinyl cardNoYes

In our reading, Thunder suits a sunny front or a white trim that needs contrast, where a lighter greige can wash out; Revere Pewter suits a shaded lot, vinyl siding or a lighter house. Our Revere Pewter HC-172 exterior guide covers that color on its own.

Thunder vs Stonington Gray, Edgecomb Gray and the similar colors on its page

The four similar colors on Thunder's page, its cool Affinity neighbor and two lighter Historical Colors grays (LRV from Benjamin Moore, ΔE2000 our calculation):

ColorLRVΔE2000 to ThunderNote
Himalayan Trek 154247.050.8Warm gray undertones (Benjamin Moore): nearly a twin
Shale 86150.471.5A little lighter and a touch warmer
La Paloma Gray 155145.621.7A little darker; described as a cool gray
Silver Fox 2108-5043.732.2Darker, a hint more red; on the vinyl card
Metropolitan AF-69049.964.5Same collection, a cool gray; on the vinyl card
Stonington Gray HC-17059.365.7About 12 points lighter and silvery
Edgecomb Gray HC-17363.096.9About 15 points lighter, a warmer greige

Under about 2, chips are a poor judge: paint the two samples side by side on the wall. Stonington Gray and Edgecomb Gray are lighter choices rather than substitutes; see our Stonington Gray HC-170 exterior guide and the Edgecomb Gray HC-173 exterior guide.

Which Benjamin Moore exterior paint for Thunder: Aura Exterior or Regal Select Exterior

Benjamin Moore's color data marks Thunder as available for exterior products. What its two main house paint lines publish on the Aura Exterior page, the Regal Select Exterior page and the two data sheets cited above. Prices vary by retailer and are not covered here.

Aura ExteriorRegal Select Exterior
How Benjamin Moore presents itIts highest-performing exterior paint, with Color Lock technologyA premium exterior paint with CleanGuard technology to repel dirt
Sheens on the product pageFlat, low lustre, satin, soft glossFlat, low lustre, soft gloss
Self-primingOn most properly prepared substratesOn most properly prepared substrates
Air and surface temperature35°F minimum, 100°F maximum surface35°F minimum, 100°F maximum surface
Coverage per gallon250 to 350 sq ft300 to 400 sq ft
Dry at 77°F, 50% RHTo touch 1 hour, recoat 4 hoursTo touch 2 hours, recoat 4 hours
Vinyl siding ruleLRV 57 or more, unless on Colors for VinylLRV 55 or more, unless on Colors for Vinyl
WarrantyLimited lifetimeLifetime limited
Data sheet readFlat, N629Low Lustre, W103 (July 2021)

Both sheets call for one or two coats; Regal Select requires two on bare substrates. Our Aura Exterior review and the Regal Select Exterior guide go through each line.

Painting conditions and how much Thunder you need

Both data sheets forbid application below 35°F (air or surface), cap the surface at 100°F, and warn that high humidity and cool temperatures lengthen dry and recoat times. Our arithmetic from the published coverage: for 1,500 sq ft of siding, two coats take about 8.6 to 12 gallons of Aura Exterior or 7.5 to 10 gallons of Regal Select Exterior; for 2,000 sq ft, count 11.4 to 16 gallons and 10 to 13.3 gallons. Both sheets add that coverage depends on surface texture and porosity.

If the house was built before 1978, assume the old paint may contain lead. Under the EPA's Renovation, Repair and Painting Program, anyone paid to disturb paint in that housing must be certified; it generally does not apply to homeowners working on their own home unless, for example, they rent out part of it. Under a homeowners association, read the HOA color rules guide and submit the exact name and code, Thunder AF-685, with your request.

Five mistakes to avoid with Thunder outside

  1. Choosing from the chip or the screen. Paint two coats on a 2 by 2 ft board beside your trim white and view it on two walls, at noon and late in the day.
  2. Putting it on vinyl. It is under both vinyl floors and off the Colors for Vinyl card: use Silver Fox, Revere Pewter or Metropolitan.
  3. Treating it as light for trim and door warranties. AZEK and Simpson draw the line at 55.
  4. A creamy trim on a west wall. Evening light, a yellow-leaning white and Thunder's own yellow add up to beige.
  5. Painting new stucco too soon. Both data sheets ask for a 30-day cure on new masonry.

See Thunder on your own house

Upload a photo and try Thunder on the siding or stucco, then switch the trim white, before you order samples.

Try Thunder on my house

For the wider range, start with our Benjamin Moore exterior paint colors guide.

Sources and references

Frequently asked questions

What color is Benjamin Moore Thunder?
Thunder AF-685 is a light mid-tone gray with a faint warm cast, a greige that stays on the gray side. Benjamin Moore describes it as an easy-to-use neutral that offers an ideal mix of warm and cool, and files it in its Affinity Color Collection. Its published RGB is 189, 184, 173 (hex #BDB8AD).
What is the LRV of Benjamin Moore Thunder?
Benjamin Moore publishes an LRV of 47.58 for Thunder AF-685: it reflects a little under half of the visible light that reaches it. That makes it a light gray, but darker than the LRV 55 or 57 lines that vinyl siding, PVC trim and some door makers use.
What are the undertones of Thunder AF-685?
A modest yellow and almost no red. Converted from its published RGB, its Lab values are about a -0.2 and b 6.2, for a chroma of about 6.2 and a hue angle near 92 degrees (our calculation). It has no pink or purple cast: it reads gray in shade and north light and takes a soft beige note in direct sun.
Is Thunder a good exterior color?
Yes on wood, fiber cement, hardboard, stucco and painted brick, with a white trim, and as a soft trim or door color on a lighter house. Benjamin Moore's color data marks it for interior and exterior use. Avoid it on vinyl siding: it is under the LRV floor in Benjamin Moore's data sheets and not on the Colors for Vinyl card.
What colors go with Benjamin Moore Thunder?
Benjamin Moore lists Vapor AF-35, Dolphin AF-715, Cloud White 967 and Smoke 2122-40 as coordinating colors. Outside, White Dove OC-17, Swiss Coffee OC-45 or Chantilly Lace OC-65 work as trim, and Hale Navy HC-154, Wrought Iron 2124-10, Kendall Charcoal HC-166 or Silhouette AF-655 as a front door or shutter color.
What is the difference between Thunder and Revere Pewter?
Mostly depth. Revere Pewter HC-172 has an LRV of 55.05 against 47.58 for Thunder, so it is about 7.5 points lighter, with nearly the same hue and slightly more warmth. By our calculation the difference is about 3.8 Delta E 2000, most of it lightness. Revere Pewter is on Benjamin Moore's Colors for Vinyl card; Thunder is not.
Can you paint vinyl siding Benjamin Moore Thunder?
Not within Benjamin Moore's guidance. The Aura Exterior data sheet rules out colors with an LRV under 57 on vinyl, and the Regal Select Exterior sheet under 55, unless the color is on the Colors for Vinyl palette. Thunder is at 47.58 and not on that card. The closest colors on it, by our calculation, are Silver Fox 2108-50, Revere Pewter HC-172 and Metropolitan AF-690.
What trim color goes with Thunder siding?
A white about 34 to 43 LRV points lighter than Thunder's 47.58. Cloud White and Vapor, both listed by Benjamin Moore with Thunder, and Swiss Coffee give a soft, tonal look; Chantilly Lace OC-65 and Decorator's White OC-149 give a crisper outline that makes Thunder look warmer.
What colors are similar to Benjamin Moore Thunder?
Benjamin Moore lists Himalayan Trek 1542 (LRV 47.05), Shale 861 (50.47), La Paloma Gray 1551 (45.62) and Silver Fox 2108-50 (43.73). By our calculation Himalayan Trek is the closest, at about 0.8 Delta E 2000, close enough that only painted samples side by side will separate them.
Is Thunder too dark for a front door or garage door?
Not for a Clopay garage door: at 47.58 it falls in the LRV 39 to 100 band, where Clopay recommends but does not require a solar reflective paint. Simpson Door, however, counts any color with an LRV of 55 or below as dark and ties warranty coverage to its Paint It Black specifications, so check your door's own instructions.

Trademarks mentioned (Sherwin-Williams, Benjamin Moore, Behr, Caparol, Brillux, Sto, Alpina, Valspar, PPG, Glidden, Dulux, Crown Trade, Sandtex, Farrow & Ball, Johnstone's, Leyland) are property of their respective owners. FacadeColorizer is independent and not affiliated with any of them. Nominative fair use under Lanham Act §1125.

Share this article with your neighborhood:

Related articles and color guides

Ready to customize your home color?

Color visualizer

Try it on YOUR photos - customize your home color

Stop guessing. Our AI analyzes your photo and renders a photorealistic color preview in 30 seconds - optimized for American homes, neighborhoods and ZIP code-level light conditions.

Start a free color simulation